The Shipwreck Arcana: Stars Below

Christopher: Guest reviewer here! I’m Jenni’s husband, Chris. It fell to me to review The Shipwreck Arcana: Stars Below mini-expansion for two reasons. First, I was the impetus for getting the game originally . Second, Jenni thought the base game was just ok, while I thought it was a really good and beautiful cooperative logic puzzle. Her original review is here; if you have not played the base game you’ll want to pause here, read the original review, and return to this page as I will be using game terms and concepts with the assumption they are familiar to you.

So, what does the mini-expansion contain? At first glance, it might seem relatively small with just five Arcana cards, but since the base game has 20 Arcana cards, that’s a 25% increase, which isn’t small at all. Each Arcana card in the base game has beautiful artwork, very much like an alternative universe deck of Tarot cards. The five new cards in this expansion maintain that style of artwork, so if you were a fan, you’ll be happy.

The change in content for The Shipwreck Arcana: Stars Below is substantial. There are two new mechanisms introduced in the new Arcana. The first is mandatory action. Tree of the new cards (The Ash, The Fall, The Thief) have gold text. The gold text indicates something mandatory that must be evaluated or completed involving fates on each turn. Even if you don’t play a fate directly on one of these Arcana, they still could fade, depending on what is displayed on the board. That leads to the second mechanism, which is variable fade conditions on two of these three new cards. When these mandatory actions are coupled with the active player’s decision of which fate to play, the logic puzzle given to the remaining players can be wonderful. For instance, The Thief has the following language “After playing somewhere else : Move a visible fate higher than your unplayed fate from another card to this one, if possible.” Depending on the visible fates, an enormous amount of information can be conveyed. There is a strong push for a player to play their lower fate on the board and keep their higher fate hidden, if that would result in no movement to The Thief card. However, if a two fate is showing, and your hidden fate is a one, you can immediately indicate to your fellow players that you have a one in the hole by playing your other fate and then moving the two to The Thief.

That’s really where The Shipwreck Arcana: Stars Below shines as a game—the dynamic between the active player trying to give as much information as possible to the other players and the other players discussing and thinking through all of the possible permutations of why the active player chose to do what they did. For those of us who love interactive cooperative puzzles, it’s amazing!

The other two cards in this mini-expansion (The Musicians and The North Wind)are more in line with the original Arcana—i.e., more mathematically straight-forward card descriptions.

The faded card powers that are on the five new cards are also somewhat of a departure from those in the base game.

Two of those powers, Help (which appears on the back of 2 different cards) and Exile, are considered so powerful that players must discard the faded card AND an additional faded card to activate them. The other two powers, Slow and Amplify, allow for creative plays thinking outside the box in that the first, after being attached to an Arcana card, makes the fates in front of that card worth only one pip, and the second increases the Arcana card that replaced it by one for doom and one for predictions.

The Shipwreck Arcana: Stars Below Kickstarter Launched today. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/meromorphgames/the-shipwreck-arcana-stars-below

If you like logic puzzles, but would prefer that they are interactive, constantly changing, and cool to look at, adding The Shipwreck Arcana: Stars Below mini-expansion to your board game collection is a no-brainer.

-------------------------------------------------

Publisher: Meromorph Games
Players: 2-5 (We played with 4 and 5)
Actual Playing Time (vs the guideline on the box): about 20 minutes per game
Game type: pattern building, deduction

Rating:

Rating scale:
OUI: I would play this game again; this game is ok. I probably would not buy this game myself but I would play it with those who own it and if someone gave it to me I would keep it.
OUI OUI: I would play this game again; this game is good. I would buy this game.
OUI OUI OUI: I LOVE THIS GAME. I MUST HAVE THIS GAME.
NON: I would not play this game again. I would return this game or give it away if it was given to me.

Board Game Review > Middara: Unintentional Malum Act 1

I don't keep my finger on the pulse of all the independent Kickstarter campaigns running at any given time. There's just too much unique content being produced month after month for me to sift through everything. I leave that to those who write previews and reviews for a living (I am an IT Consultant for a living; I write reviews as a hobby because I'm passionate about board gaming). The only way an independent Kickstarter campaign is going to be on my radar is if the designer/publisher reaches out to me to let me know the campaign is running or if it's created a bit of buzz already in the key circles that I frequent. I definitely wasn't closely monitoring Kickstarter campaigns four years ago when the original edition of Middara was initially funded. It was an adventurous dungeon crawl that promised to be so much more than an ordinary dungeon crawl. With options to run in campaign mode for an ongoing narrative or crawl mode for one off gameplay, it could work as a...

Board Game Review: Anno 1800

Whenever Martin Wallace designs a new game, I am all over it. This is because I absolutely love Brass Birmingham (another MW designed game); in fact Brass Birmingham is my #1 board game of all time. Over the years, his other games I've tried have been pretty good, but not necessarily amazing must-buys. Still, I keep trying each new release of his, searching for that next star performer. That's why I'm excited to report that Anno 1800 is, in fact, a star performer, and an amazing must-buy board game. Anno 1800 was adapted by the publisher (Kosmos) from a Ubisoft video game of the same name. In the board game, players take on the role of industrialists, charged with developing their island economies and exploring other islands. Each player begins the game with a personal industry board with trade & exploration ships, a shipyard, and industrial goods tiles printed on the board. A starting collection of workers (wooden cubes) of various types to produce the goods is a...

Board Game Review: Clank! Legacy: Acquisitions Incorporated (spoiler free)

We’ve had our eye on Clank! Legacy: Acquisitions Incorporated since its debut in 2019 from Renegade Game Studios. In our house, we love legacy games and we own most of the other Clank! editions, so it seemed like a good fit. Boy, was it ever! We finally got the game a couple of weeks ago, and immediately fell for it so hard during the first few minutes of the game that we played it nearly every day with our 11 year old twin sons, Max and Locke. In Clank! Legacy: AI , designed by Andy Clautice and Paul Dennen, players take on the role of employees at a small organization. At the beginning of the legacy campaign, the organization is in the process of applying to become a franchise of Acquisitions Incorporated, a megacorp famed for its for-profit adventuring services. We loved the narrative and appreciated the touches of authenticity, like the franchise charter agreement. We’ve played through other legacy campaign games over the past year where the narrative fell flat at tim...